top of page

Employment Tribunals: What They Cost and How to Never End up in One

Writer: Shona Hamilton
Shona Hamilton
Nov 9
4 min read

An employee submits a claim against your business. In the current climate, the conversation isn’t about whether the claim has merit. It’s about whether you can afford to wait two years for an outcome.


Employment tribunal

The Tribunal Landscape

TThe earliest version of employment tribunals were the industrial tribunals set up in the 1960s to handle training levy appeals from employers. As employment law expanded through the 1970s and 1990s, their remit grew to cover redundancy payments, equal pay, and sex discrimination. The Employment Protection Act 1975 extended their role to unfair dismissal, and they were renamed employment tribunals in 1998.


In 2013, a fee system was introduced which cut tribunal claims by two thirds. The Supreme Court ruled it unlawful in 2017, fees were abolished, and claims surged. The backlog has never recovered. There are currently around 70,000 cases outstanding, with hearing dates being scheduled for 2028 and 2029.

The Qualifying Period - a History of Political Football


Here’s something most employers don’t know: the qualifying period for unfair dismissal has been changing since the 1970s, and it’s always been driven by whoever is in power.


  • 1971 - Statutory right to claim unfair dismissal introduced after two years’ service

  • 1974 - Reduced to six months under Labour

  • 1979 - Back up to one year under the Conservatives

  • 1980 - Raised to two years for small businesses

  • 1985 - Extended to all employees

  • 1999 - Reduced back to one year under New Labour

  • 2012 - Back up to two years under the Coalition, to reduce regulatory burden on business

  • 2027 - Set to drop to six months under the current government


See the pattern? The system has always been political. And if you’re not tracking how changes affect you, you’re already behind.


What's Coming to Tribunals and Why It Matters Now

It’s not just the qualifying period changing.


From January 2027, the government is also looking to remove the cap on unfair dismissal compensation awards entirely. And if ACAS best practice hasn’t been followed, tribunals may be able to add a 20% uplift on top of any award.


So the likelihood of a claim has increased. The potential cost of losing one is increasing too.


What a Tribunal Actually Costs?

The financial cost varies hugely depending on the type of claim - but it’s never just one number.


Tribunal Legal Fees

Depending on the type of claim whether that's unpaid wages, unfair dismissal, discrimination or whistleblowing, your legal fees could land anywhere between £4,000 and £55,000+.


Barrister Fees

If you need representation at the hearing itself, add £1,000 to £2,500 per day.


Compensation Awards

At the time of writing, the maximum award for unfair dismissal is £118,223 (or one year's gross salary, whichever is lower). Awards for discrimination or whistleblowing for example are already uncapped with average payouts for sex or disability discrimination regularly exceeding £50k. Plus tribunals can award up to £58,700 for severe cases of injury to feelings.


Hidden Costs

Management time is the cost nobody talks about. Collating evidence, preparing bundles for solicitors and attending hearings can drain anywhere from £3,000 - £10,000 in lost productivity as key members of staff end up diverted away from running the business.


It's also important to consider reputational damage that can be done if a tribunal claim against your business succeeds. Once a claim has been settled (regardless of the outcome) the records become publicly available.


And then there's the thing that doesn't have a price tag: having a court case hanging over your business for up to two years. The stress, the uncertainty, the distraction. As a busines owner, that cost alone feels like reason enough to get this right.


Top Five Things That Land Employers at Tribunal


Most claims aren't random. They're the result of the same avoidable mistakes, repeated:


  • No process or failure to follow a process

  • Dismissal without a fair reason

  • Lack of documentation throughout

  • Inconsistent treatment of employees

  • Moving too fast when things go wrong


How to Avoid Tribunals

The good news is that most tribunal claims are preventable. Here’s what actually makes the difference:


Get your contracts and policies in place before you need them, not after. A policy that doesn’t exist can’t protect you.


Read and follow your own policies. And if all else fails, follow a fair process every single time - even when it feels disproportionate to the situation.


Document everything. Not just outcomes, but the conversations, the meetings, and the decisions along the way. If it isn’t written down, it didn’t happen.


Take advice early. Prevention is always cheaper than a cure. If something feels like it’s heading somewhere difficult, pick up the phone before you act.


Use probation properly. Actively manage and support new starters rather than letting them drift - and remember, from January 2027, the protection window gets much shorter.


Deal with problems when they arise. There’s no room for ostriches here. The longer something festers, the harder and more expensive it becomes to resolve.


Two years. Tens of thousands of pounds. That’s what’s waiting at the end of a process that went wrong. Most tribunal claims are preventable - not because the employer got lucky, but because they got the basics right, consistently, before anything had a chance to escalate.


If you want to sense-check your current processes, or you’re already dealing with something that feels like it’s heading in the wrong direction, we can help.

Comments


bottom of page